THE LEADMILL

DOES SHEFFIELD HOLD SHEFFIELD BACK? A DIFFERENT TAKE ON THE LEADMILL

OPINION

I live in Sheffield and have been involved in bringing cultural events, community festivals, live music, comedy, and big public celebrations to life in Sheffield for over 30 years. 

Like many Sheffield folk I have many happy memories of nights at The Leadmill. My Parents met there in the 60s when it was The Esquire, and my late brother met his wife there in the 90s when it was The Leadmill.

But one thing I’ve definitely learnt on my journey in the creative sector is that everything changes all the time, and that’s a good and necessary thing. That building has already had at least three different cultural lives: first as The Esquire Club, then The Leadmill as a not-for-profit community arts organisation, and in recent years it became a fully commercial operation under Phil Mills.  To be honest, when I was last there a few weeks ago it was looking tired, rather unloved and desperately in need of investment.

When Mr. Mills passed on the opportunity to buy the freehold in 2016, it was pretty much inevitable that the building would be sold, either to a property developer or to a new venue operator. And that’s exactly what happened with Dominic Madden and the Electric Group. Frankly, Dominic has saved that space from being turned into student flats, and he clearly has the money, energy, experience and drive to make the place great again.

I, for one, was horrified by the aggressive, cynical, and disingenuous campaign launched against Madden and the Electric Group.  I was embarrassed for our city. What kind of message does that send about bringing in new investment and being open to fresh ideas and new people?

Our Son was at university in Newcastle and absolutely raved about their NX venue there. I also have friends & family in Bristol and London who go to gigs at their venues and speak very highly of their operation.

I’m 57 now, and most of my memories of The Leadmill are from when I was between 18 and 22. At its core, that building has always been about great music and cool events for young people. It’s clear that The Electric Group will bring an even better programme because they can offer artists and promoters multi-venue deals and this will be appreciated and enjoyed by a new generation of young people. It’s their turn now.

It’s perfectly okay to be a little sad about something changing, but still be excited for the next phase. I truly believe that what the Electric Group will bring is a fourth act for the building, and then in thirty years’ time, everything might change again!

I’ve lived in Sheffield my entire life, and I love this place, but we really do need to be careful that we don’t close ourselves off to the new and cling on to the old and, at times, tired. Saying that the Leadmill can’t change seems a bit like saying Richard Hawley (who I was at school with) or Pulp cant release a new album because we love their early work so much.

There was also a strong element of “but he’s not local” in the campaign and I am reminded that so many of the great Artistic Directors at Sheffield Theatres have not been local either. The “Soul of Sheffield” nonsense sounded to me like something from Royston Vasey – “Local Clubs for Local People”. What arrogance to decide that you are the arbiter of the soul of a city of 600,000 people, and that the future of that soul depends on the outcome of your commercial lease dispute.

There have been rumours locally that the current operator is planning to take a sledgehammer to the place which, if true would be appalling and hugely counterproductive. Much of the work inside that building was paid for in the 80s/90s by the people of Sheffield when Sheffield Council gave grants to the then not for profit organisation. More recently taxpayer money was used to make improvements from a Covid grant. In a wider sense the venue belongs to its Patrons and I don’t think any of those will want to see the place smashed up.

So, as a City can we please draw a line, be open to fresh ideas, new people and now support this amazing space as it evolves further.

Hopefully, in a couple of years we might agree that the change has been for the greater good.

Words by Scott Barton.

CHECK OUT THE LATEST TRENDING MUSIC INDUSTRY NEWS HERE

THE LEADMILL
Cheif